| matchup | | result | win | loss | save | |
|---|
| Chicago CHW | | CHW 8, BOS 4 | Brandon Eisert | Zack Kelly | | |
| Cincinnati CIN | | CIN 24, BAL 2 | Taylor Rogers | Charlie Morton | Randall Wynne | |
| Cleveland CLE | | CLE 5, PIT 4 (F/10) | Emmanuel Clase | Dennis Santana | Joey Cantillo | |
| Miami MIA | | MIA 7, PHI 5 (F/10) | Calvin Faucher | Matt Strahm | Jesus Tinoco | |
| Minnesota MIN | | ATL 6, MIN 2 | Grant Holmes | Joe Ryan | | |
| Seattle SEA | | SEA 8, TOR 3 | Luis Castillo | Easton Lucas | | |
| Kansas City KC | | KC 4, DET 3 (F/10) | Carlos Estevez | Tyler Holton | | |
| New York NYY | | NYY 4, TB 0 | Max Fried | Ryan Pepiot | Fernando Cruz | |
| St. Louis STL | | NYM 7, STL 4 | Jose Butto | JoJo Romero | | |
| Athletics ATH | | MIL 14, ATH 1 | Logan Henderson | Jeffrey Springs | Tyler Alexander | |
| Arizona ARI | | ARI 3, CHC 2 (F/11) | Shelby Miller | Jordan Wicks | Drey Jameson | |
| Los Angeles LAD | | LAD 1, TEX 0 | Ben Casparius | Chris Martin | Tanner Scott | |
| Washington WSH | | WSH 3, COL 2 | Jake Irvin | Kyle Freeland | Kyle Finnegan | |
| San Francisco SF | | LAA 5, SF 4 | Michael Darrell-Hicks | Ryan Walker | | |
| Washington WSH | | COL 3, WSH 1 | Antonio Senzatela | Brad Lord | Tyler Kinley | |
